Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Connie Passalacqua Hayman's avatar

Roger, this is terrific! It is so well-written and informative. I became addicted to soaps as a teen watching the Steve-Alice-Rachel triangle and I dearly loved “Another World.”— And some of the greatest names in soaps passed through that show—Reinholt, Strasser, Courtney, Dano, Schnetzer Rauch, Lemay and on and on. I’d love to watch it all again!

Lynn Liccardo's avatar

Roger —

Great deep dive into a complex and contentious issue. This piece brought me back to a question I posed about Irna Phillips back in 2009: “what would Irna think?” At the time, I was curious about what she would have thought about Guiding Light’s move from the studio to Peapack. But expanding soaps to an hour?

Irna died in 1973, so it’s hard to say for sure. She certainly would have appreciated the possibilities for richer and deeper storytelling. Those were the arguments she made to p&g when she wanted to expand Guiding Light from 15 minutes to a half hour. when P&G refused, she partnered with Ted Corday and Agnes Nixon to create and finance the pilot for As the World Turns — $10,000 ($120,000+ in today’s dollars).

Of course, since the idea was coming from the NBC. She had always wanted Another World to go to CBS, so she certainly would have had some skepticism and perhaps even anticipated the downsides.

Lots to consider — but, as I said — hard to know for sure.

Also: a correction:

You quote Bill Bell: “We were the first place show when we went an hour [in February 1980]. You want to know what happened? It took us four years to regain that position. Four years.” Except in February 1980, The Young and the Restless was #3, behind General Hospital and All My Children. Y&R would become #1 until the 1988-89 season.

Bill Bell died in 2005 from Alzheimers. The interview — really an illuminating conversation between him and Claire Labine — took place in 1997, when the effects Alzheimers were likely already apparent. I’ve watched his 1998 interview for Television: An Oral History and there are also numerous misrememberings resulting from the Alzheimers.

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?